Saturday, June 6, 2020

Amy Cooper and the Gaslighting of Racism in America

Comedian Ray Romano highlighted many of the events and relationship foibles of marriage and family life in his sitcom Everybody Loves Raymond. In one episode that I always found particularly thought-provoking, Ray and his father try to teach his newly-engaged brother how to pretend incompetence at a task, so that he won't have to complete a job his fiance has asked him to do. In predictable sitcom fashion, everything goes wrong, the men get exposed for their pretend incompetence, and a battle between men and wives breaks out. In the end, though, the women lose their upper hand when the men figure out that perhaps their wives have been pretending incompetence at tasks they don't want to do as well. The thing that sticks most in my memory about this entire episode is the dawning look of outrage and vindication on Ray's face when he experiences the sudden realization that Debra actually could learn how to set the VCR.


Everyone's reason for pretending in this episode, of course, is to avoid taking responsibility. If you can't understand what needs to be done, you obviously can't be expected to do anything about it. Both sides in this story rationalize their behavior differently--the men claim that the women "really want to do everything themselves anyway", and the women say they "already do everything else", so both feel justified in their pretense. But then why pretend? Well, that's simple. If everyone admitted that they could understand the needs and were capable of meeting them, they would also have had to admit that they just didn't want to do what was needed.

Racism in America is a longstanding, complex problem that is deeply rooted in our emotions, our identities, our beliefs about and experiences of ourselves and others. Facing it and making attempts to address it can seem overwhelming, especially for white Americans on whom the bulk of this burden must rest. It can require us to see things that are very hurtful and upsetting, about our world, others who we care about, and ourselves. It can cause us to make some painful recalculations about the way we have understood people, events, and stories in the past. It can necessitate that we change our thoughts, ideas, language, and many aspects of our behavior. It is our job, but there is no question--it will make us uncomfortable, and it will give us difficult work to do. It has been far easier, I am afraid, to simply say, "Oh, you know I can never figure out that VCR."

Our black friends, co-workers, and community members have been trying for time long remembered to make us see the need, but as white people, we have been very convincing in our inability to see or understand. We have been so convincing that I believe at times we have convinced ourselves; some of us really do believe that we think the issue is about respect for the flag, or that we are hurt on behalf of other lives that should also matter. No matter how many statistic are cited, no matter how many stories are told, no matter how many videos surface, we have still responded in numbers too large by saying that we just don't see the problem that black people are talking about, or that we can't understand the issues being raised as ones of racism. In a recent survey on race issues, 77% of Republican participants said that this country's biggest racial problem was "seeing discrimination where it does not exist." (I'm not picking on Republicans at all; the survey data is reported this way for several reasons, one of which is to account for the factor of race.)

It has been easier, white friends, to not see the problem. By which I mean it has been easier for us. Our insisted-upon lack of understanding and racial incompetence has allowed us to excuse ourselves from responsibility; it has left our friends of color to bear the consequences and do the work;  it has created the illusion that they are the ones "being crazy", being unreasonable, creating problems.  This is gaslighting at its finest. After all, if we acknowledged to our black brothers and sisters that we could see and understand the problem--if we acknowledged this even to ourselves--we would have to admit that we have simply chosen to do nothing, that we do not want to do what is needed. But Amy Cooper has changed all that.

When Amy Cooper encountered Christian Cooper in Central Park's Ramble this Memorial Day, as the confrontation escalated, most of us have seen that moment on video when she pointed her finger at him and announced she intended to call the police and tell them that "an African-American man is threatening my life." I cannot know what that moment was like for people of color. But I know what I imagined it might be like. I imagined Ray Romano's face, learning that Debra knew how to set the VCR. Amy Cooper's mask came off, both literally and figuratively as that threat was made, and with it, the mask of all white America. It is impossible not to see that she knew her threat was meaningful precisely because of racism. Without meaning to, she stripped the facade from our pretense of incompetence and incomprehension. Amy Cooper pulls back the curtain, and we can no longer escape the discomfort, the work, or the pain by pretending not to see. Amy Cooper proves we have had the ability to see all along.

Saturday, April 11, 2020

Saturday

All great stories have a moment when all is lost.

We're drawn to these stories, these tales of narrow victory over defeat, the last-minute success of the rebels just when things are at their blackest and it looks like the Empire has won. Something in them speaks to our soul, I think. There is a reason why we feel ourselves drawn to the underdog, that unlikely champion, who proves in the end that love and truth are more powerful than whatever seemingly inconquerable forces have been amassed against him. The more impossible his triumph appears, the more joyful, the more just it seems.

This Passion week is no exception. As we commemorate that Greatest Story, we remember not just the joy, but that the champion falls, the lion dies, the messiah is in the tomb. Salvation is not just snatched from the jaws of loss at the last moment--it is actually swallowed up in defeat. Death has the victory. There are three days of mourning.

We understand that it had to happen this way because you cannot truly, fully defeat something until it first defeats you. Otherwise, your victory is hollow; there is always the chance that it might be overthrown, should some greater challenge arise. Every true champion must defeat the strongest enemy, must neutralize the greatest threat, must do so at the height of its power. Death must do its worst.

In this Easter season, I sometimes hear it said or preached, "It's Friday, but Sunday's coming!' We hold out the promise that just when things seem darkest, the greatest of victories is just around the corner. How easy it is to see, for all of us Monday morning quarterbacks. As we celebrate now, so far in the future, we have the advantage of hindsight that removes any element of suspense or doubt. We know the end of the story. Even though the battle is lost, the war is not over--the enemy trembles, the table cracks, the King rises up. From our vantage point, where, then, is death's sting? But truly, in that interval of defeat, hindsight is not present. Death has triumphed, and it is the ultimate power in the universe. All is lost. In that time of mourning, between Friday and Sunday, the future is uncertain. We do not know what will happen next--all we know is what has happened now.

The only hope of victory must come by faith--it cannot come by sight. And right now, I find that I can't muster the confidence to be so certain. The immediate truth of loss is so present, so powerful. I have lost my sense of the ancient magic. Sunday may come, with its promise of resurrection, of restoration, of life; but I am stuck in Saturday, and today, I've seen with my own eyes that death has the victory. I wait in the dark, which is always where hope comes. I do not know what will happen next.

Sunday, December 29, 2019

The One Thing

There's so much in life, I find, that needs fixing. It seems like every day, there are things that just don't go the way they should. Things break. Plans fail. People disappoint. Life is full of bumps and bruises, pains and problems.

Some of us are problem-solvers. We take joy in fixing these things, both for ourselves and others. Our fix-it impulses pull us into situations all the way from small appliance repair to major life crises, all with the same motivation--to make everything all right. I guarantee you, though, that even those of us who are problem solvers--maybe especially us--also need fixing. And beyond fixing, we need healing, mending. Always, for everyone, the journey of simply being alive in the world has brought hurts, shame, and pain to us in ways that are deep and shaping. Who or what can help us mend?

In most cases, I believe that significant relationships are where we find healing and wholeness, relief from the pains and brokenness of our past. And in my life, Rick was the fixer. He knew how to fix a sump pump, reboot the wifi, unclog a toilet. He could help think through difficult decisions, bring clarity to hard conversations, find guidance in confusing situations. He was always willing to offer his own hard work, practical help, and reflective wisdom. He could stop a whole evening of family fighting in my house, just by showing up. Wherever he went, he brought with him an aura of calm, and left behind a wake of peace.

For me, he not only smoothed the rough edges of daily living, but his healing touch sank deeply into my past, into hurts and griefs and false beliefs that have shaped me in painful and destructive ways since childhood. Listening to him preach every Sunday, listening to him talk in our everyday conversations, just seeing him live in a way that brought lofty truths to intimate life, helped me shape a new understanding of beliefs that have always been a part of me. I learned from him to see grace and love in new ways. Always, I've labored to meet the standards of my own faith, to do well at doing right. But Rick's faith was not about being right or doing right; it had room for failure, room for weakness, room for doubt. The grace I've offered myself has been dispensed sparingly, as a necessity. The grace Rick spoke of and lived out was never grudging, never stingy--it was generous, joyful, more than enough. Love, in the pictures Rick painted, was about others. It was never about how to change anyone, fix anyone. It was only about extending itself out, inviting others in. And most of all, love was for everyone, the ultimate truth. It was lavish and unconditional, welcoming and complete. It was the core truth of our existence, for ourselves, for others, and as the foundation for a community of the Beloved. It was for me.

In my adult life, love and I had not done well together. Love had meant revolving in orbit around someone else and their needs, always in the shadow; Rick showed me that it meant emerging into the light, having someone else rejoice in my happiness and success. All the love I had to give had fallen into a black hole, a chasm that could not be filled, absorbed like tiny pinpricks of light being consumed by the darkness; and so, no matter how much, it had never been enough. I learned now that love can be received with joy and returned; and when it is, it is multiplied many times over, making love increase for both the giver and the receiver, until giving and receiving are indistinguishable acts and there is nothing but more, hundreds and thousands of times more love. In all the broken places where I had lost sight of my own beauty, he found it and gave it back to me, reflecting it back in a thousand truthful glimpses with the simplest of daily interactions. Before, love in my life was like a cactus, its sparse beauty surviving and even thriving sometimes on the tiny streams of water buried deeply in the sand, perhaps able even to burst into flower with the faintest sprinkling of rain, yet with pain and danger always present. Love with Rick was like a lush and spreading old-growth apple tree, green and inviting, fragrant with blossoms, cool and shady, heavy with fruit, bursting with fire. Its peaceful beauty nourished the soul in every season.

And now, I suppose, comes winter, when it lies sleeping, bare and silent in the cold.

Once, after a tearful outburst over some hurt or frustration, with my face buried in his shoulder and his arms around me, I asked plaintively, "Is there anything you can't make better?" With that slow, self-deprecating chuckle, he said drily, "Oh, I imagine there's a thing or two."

I didn't believe you then, my dear. After all, you mended everything in me that was broken. As always, though, I know now that you were right. I've found the one thing that you can't fix. I don't blame you; even your powers had to have their limit. But even though you cannot come this time and make everything all right, rest assured, rick champ--you are still the only one.

How I love you.

Wednesday, November 13, 2019

New Every Morning

I'm writing this at 9:00 on a Wednesday night. Wrapped up in a cozy blanket on my couch, drink at hand, with the cold wind blowing outside, I feel able to sit in my quiet house and think, reflect, pray, even write. I am able to have everyday conversations about trivial matters with my son as he wanders by. In fact, I feel as if I might be OK. Tomorrow's tasks seem surmountable. I make plans for the day. They start, obviously, with getting out of bed, which seems, at the moment, so easy.

 And then I go to bed, and sleep.

Sleep is what I need right now, everyone tells me, and I'm certainly doing enough of it. I know it's good for both my body and soul, and it is a blessed reprieve from consciousness, if I can say it that way. The trouble with sleep is, it comes to an end with the morning. And in the morning, it's a whole new ball game.

On that first terrible day, when I took to my bed for the first time, I explained to Laura why I needed to re-read Option B, the book on resilience that Sheryl Sandberg wrote after the sudden death of her husband. "I don't remember anything she said!" I wailed, sobbing, "Not any of it! I don't know how to be resilient!" And Laura, always wise, said calmly, "She wasn't resilient on Day Zero. You don't have to do that now."

How comforting--what a relief it was--to know that I didn't need to be resilient, didn't need to be strong, didn't need to be able to get up and start again, there on that first day in the heart of my grief. And Laura was right. It's no longer Day Zero. But still, every morning, I wake up to realize my loss in some ways as if it's the first time. I find that whatever gains, whatever strength, I seem to have acquired the day before have disappeared. I am starting again at square one. It's as if I am caught in a bizarre cross between the movies Groundhog Day and 50 First Dates, where each day repeats itself just like the one before, and on each day there is a terrible truth that I must learn. The pain is new every morning, and every morning, it's just as hard to get out of bed as it was the day before.

Some days I don't make it.

In some part of my brain, none of this makes sense. I grow impatient with myself, uncomprehending of what could possibly be so difficult. Always, I have been a person who kept moving in the face of hardship, who fulfilled my responsibilities no matter the obstacle, and this is what I have come to expect from myself. But always in the past, I have faced an enemy who remains known over time, who doesn't change from moment to moment--never one like this that is fresh with each new look, each new thought, each new day.

In the actual movie 50 First Dates, Lucy does start to adjust more quickly every day. It's not that the terrible truth isn't still there to learn, but learning it becomes easier, little by little, and there's room for it to be seen alongside the joy and meaning that is also present in life. Faithful friends tell me that this is how it will be for me also, in some ways--that loss doesn't change, but it somehow gets easier, makes room for other things. That when I'm ready, getting out of bed won't be so hard.

I'm grateful for people around me who understand this better than I do. I'm grateful for those who have assured me that time will heal, even though from my vantage point that time seems far away. I'm grateful for the prayers offered by friends, acquaintances, and even strangers on my behalf. And I'm hopeful that as grief continues to be new every morning, there will be new grace to meet it.

Because of the Lord’s great love we are not consumed,
for his compassions never fail.
They are new every morning;
great is your faithfulness.
(Lamentations 3:22–23 NIV)