Showing posts with label abject failure. Show all posts
Showing posts with label abject failure. Show all posts

Saturday, June 6, 2020

Amy Cooper and the Gaslighting of Racism in America

Comedian Ray Romano highlighted many of the events and relationship foibles of marriage and family life in his sitcom Everybody Loves Raymond. In one episode that I always found particularly thought-provoking, Ray and his father try to teach his newly-engaged brother how to pretend incompetence at a task, so that he won't have to complete a job his fiance has asked him to do. In predictable sitcom fashion, everything goes wrong, the men get exposed for their pretend incompetence, and a battle between men and wives breaks out. In the end, though, the women lose their upper hand when the men figure out that perhaps their wives have been pretending incompetence at tasks they don't want to do as well. The thing that sticks most in my memory about this entire episode is the dawning look of outrage and vindication on Ray's face when he experiences the sudden realization that Debra actually could learn how to set the VCR.


Everyone's reason for pretending in this episode, of course, is to avoid taking responsibility. If you can't understand what needs to be done, you obviously can't be expected to do anything about it. Both sides in this story rationalize their behavior differently--the men claim that the women "really want to do everything themselves anyway", and the women say they "already do everything else", so both feel justified in their pretense. But then why pretend? Well, that's simple. If everyone admitted that they could understand the needs and were capable of meeting them, they would also have had to admit that they just didn't want to do what was needed.

Racism in America is a longstanding, complex problem that is deeply rooted in our emotions, our identities, our beliefs about and experiences of ourselves and others. Facing it and making attempts to address it can seem overwhelming, especially for white Americans on whom the bulk of this burden must rest. It can require us to see things that are very hurtful and upsetting, about our world, others who we care about, and ourselves. It can cause us to make some painful recalculations about the way we have understood people, events, and stories in the past. It can necessitate that we change our thoughts, ideas, language, and many aspects of our behavior. It is our job, but there is no question--it will make us uncomfortable, and it will give us difficult work to do. It has been far easier, I am afraid, to simply say, "Oh, you know I can never figure out that VCR."

Our black friends, co-workers, and community members have been trying for time long remembered to make us see the need, but as white people, we have been very convincing in our inability to see or understand. We have been so convincing that I believe at times we have convinced ourselves; some of us really do believe that we think the issue is about respect for the flag, or that we are hurt on behalf of other lives that should also matter. No matter how many statistic are cited, no matter how many stories are told, no matter how many videos surface, we have still responded in numbers too large by saying that we just don't see the problem that black people are talking about, or that we can't understand the issues being raised as ones of racism. In a recent survey on race issues, 77% of Republican participants said that this country's biggest racial problem was "seeing discrimination where it does not exist." (I'm not picking on Republicans at all; the survey data is reported this way for several reasons, one of which is to account for the factor of race.)

It has been easier, white friends, to not see the problem. By which I mean it has been easier for us. Our insisted-upon lack of understanding and racial incompetence has allowed us to excuse ourselves from responsibility; it has left our friends of color to bear the consequences and do the work;  it has created the illusion that they are the ones "being crazy", being unreasonable, creating problems.  This is gaslighting at its finest. After all, if we acknowledged to our black brothers and sisters that we could see and understand the problem--if we acknowledged this even to ourselves--we would have to admit that we have simply chosen to do nothing, that we do not want to do what is needed. But Amy Cooper has changed all that.

When Amy Cooper encountered Christian Cooper in Central Park's Ramble this Memorial Day, as the confrontation escalated, most of us have seen that moment on video when she pointed her finger at him and announced she intended to call the police and tell them that "an African-American man is threatening my life." I cannot know what that moment was like for people of color. But I know what I imagined it might be like. I imagined Ray Romano's face, learning that Debra knew how to set the VCR. Amy Cooper's mask came off, both literally and figuratively as that threat was made, and with it, the mask of all white America. It is impossible not to see that she knew her threat was meaningful precisely because of racism. Without meaning to, she stripped the facade from our pretense of incompetence and incomprehension. Amy Cooper pulls back the curtain, and we can no longer escape the discomfort, the work, or the pain by pretending not to see. Amy Cooper proves we have had the ability to see all along.

Wednesday, May 1, 2019

All Things New


Come broken and weary
Come battered and bruised
My Jesus makes all things new
All things new

Come lost and abandoned
Come blown by the wind
He'll bring you back home again
Home again

Rise up, oh you sleeper, awake
The light of the dawn is upon you
Rise up, oh you sleeper, awake
He makes all things new
All things new


Recently, at Salt & Light, we had something new happen. Someone who was a part of our community left us. By itself, this isn't unusual. We are creating a motley, beautiful, strangely assorted family here, and it's messy. People often leave for various reasons--some exciting, such as a great move or a new job, and some a little less joyous, such as incarceration, hospitalization, or job termination. This time, though, one of our community departed through death. We lost our longtime volunteer and receptionist, Donna.

Donna was on my reception team, and she and I got to know each other well over the years we have worked together. There is pain in her story, as with many who come to Salt & Light. (If you are interested in hearing more about her journey, the first two minutes of this video will paint a better picture, but I'll warn you, I need the tissues at 1:47 every. Single. Time.)  Her unique experience equipped her with a few of what her son, at her funeral service, lovingly described to me as her "quirks".

It would be easy, if you didn't know the whole story, to see some of these quirks of Donna's as flaws, instead of the remarkable gifts that they were. For example, at first glance, she may have seemed like a fragile person. Even she felt that way sometimes, I think, as we all do. But in her life, the things she had overcome seem nearly insurmountable. She had carried a heavier load than I can imagine bearing. She had endured things that might have ended me. Even now, her own medical issues were overwhelming, and every day, her body tried to betray her in some new way, but no matter how exhausting or difficult her circumstance became, she continued to find new ways to work around, to accommodate, to overcome and keep going. Her strength amazed me--I wish I could aspire to a fraction of it.

She also seemed to be easily frightened, sometimes by small things--it was easy to startle her by appearing too suddenly in the doorway behind her. But in reality, her bravery was astonishing. She had faced terror and death in her own experience; she had taken enormous risks to save her life, herself, her children. She was intimately aware of every way, every day, that danger and harm lurk just out of sight. And yet she faced those odds, on her own, unblinking, every day that she went out to face the world.

Sometimes Donna seemed to say just the wrong thing at just the wrong time, in just the wrong way. But in my office, next to the reception desk, I can overhear the conversations with callers and people who walk in to the front desk, and I know how many times Donna's "wrong thing" was just the right thing for someone. She spoke to everyone with a response she thought would be right for someone who was hurting or afraid; she assumed that was true of everyone she spoke to. And isn't it, really? I have heard her throw that lifeline out to so many, and many times she has thrown it out to me, by making that assumption. I envied her the wisdom, sometimes, to have the right words for people who are barely hanging on.

Donna saw the darkness but looked for the light. Every day I saw her we laughed. She knew how to find happiness and gratitude in the smallest things. I believe this is not in spite of, but because she was so well-acquainted with all the ways that pain and loss can come to us in this life. Heartache sharpens your senses for joy. It's a heavy burden to carry, however--this load of suffering that is not only your own, but belongs to others, belongs to the world. That wisdom in grief comes at a cost. Your spirit, however content, grows weary.

I was on a six-week medical leave when I got the call, and hadn't seen Donna in person for more than a month. I didn't get to say goodbye. I miss her. I take some comfort, though, in her last words to me, a text that said, "I know, because you always tell me, that I am so strong." I hope that this small gift I seem to have given her was even a small bit of what she gave to me in the time we knew each other.  She had begun to talk, recently, of moving to Florida, a place she had only visited once, but she spoke with such longing of being somewhere that her soul felt at peace. Donna was not afraid to die, and I admit, my grief at her passing is not sadness for her, but selfishly, is simple pain at my own loss.

I realize that since the moment I heard that she had left, had gone to sleep and kept on sleeping, I have been thinking of this Andrew Peterson song, All Things New, as "Donna's song." I think it would speak to her, my friend who knew so intimately about brokenness, pain, and loss, and who nevertheless celebrated each small joy in the world.  Every day, Donna got up again, no matter how huge the obstacles or how great the cost, to face the darkness and to try, once again, with all her might, to make things a little brighter. And now at last, there is nothing left to do but rise up--wake up to what she hoped and longed for.

My Jesus makes all things new.

Friday, April 26, 2019

White on White

In an earlier post, I wrote about a thread on Facebook, on the page of a popular black blogger, in which she prompted her black readers to ask white readers one question that they'd always wanted to know. In that previous post, I described how, while the thread contained a great deal of good discussion and what seemed to be real discovery for many people, there was also a theme that kept popping up among white respondents who did not find themselves identifying with some of the questions that were asked. Time after time, commenters who were white, but did not recognize themselves in some particular aspect of a question, responded by giving some version of the answer "I guess I must not really be white," or even, "I guess I must be black."

This joke, I wrote, can be a joke for people who have the option of seeing their race as inconsequential. Like other serious subjects, it is easy to joke about if it has not touched you in ways that are painful or difficult. If it is not a matter of life or death.

Today, however, I'd like to pose a different question. And that is, when is a joke not a joke?

I think that most of us haven't reached adulthood without realizing that at the root of all jokes is some kernel of truth, or at least the intention of one. All of us, I imagine, have at some point been on the receiving end of a "joking" statement that hit too close to home, or was knowingly meant to hurt. That's a negative example, but there are positive ones also--in fact, I'd guess that most of the jokes that the majority of us encounter in our lives are well-meaning, and often occur without any conscious intentional subtext. Nevertheless, it's the truth behind the joke that makes it funny, and I also think that can tell us something important about what the speaker is really saying, even if it's not something they are conscious of trying to communicate.

In all these responses where white people joked about not being white, I believe there was an intended kernel of truth that is important to see and name. Despite all the protests admonishing me to lighten up, enjoy the fun, and appreciate the joke when I suggested that maybe the joke wasn't appropriate, I believe that at some level, the joke wasn't really even a joke.

What I heard, over and over, was a striving to separate from whiteness--to say, "I'm not THAT kind of white." Some people even went farther in putting this into words. I saw responses that said, "There is Florida person white and other person white." More than one person adopted, "I am invited-to-the-cookout white and you are I-want-to-see-the-manager white." As a white person, I heard other white people working hard to say two things. First, "I am one of the good white people. No, really. I'm a good one." And second, "I'm like you. We think alike. I know just what you're talking about. All those other white people might be clueless as hell, but I get it."

I believe I can hear these things being said because I can identify with the impulse to say them. I think our shared history in this country, a history of racism and oppression, acknowledged by all, not only has deep roots on which we are all drawing, but casts long shadows in which we are all still living. Racial discrimination and inequality in this country are not things of the past. And while both the marginalized and the privileged may wish it were so, we are coming to that wish with different motivations, and often with different understandings of how to make that reality.

People and communities of color understand that the only way to overcome and move forward from our past is to face it head on. Our legacy of racism and injustice must be acknowledged honestly in order to be reckoned with. But for those of us whose white skin has afforded us generations of privilege at the expense of people of color, there can be a deep desire to move away from the shameful heritage of oppression in our past by a process of disassociation--to say, "I am not one of the people who caused this, I am not one who perpetuates it, I have no desire to prolong it." We feel the need to distinguish ourselves from the bad actors of both the past and the present. This is not only because it is painful to connect ourselves to unjustifiable wrongdoing, but because it is difficult to admit that our connection to it could create feelings of anger, resentment, and animosity, and that it's reasonable and appropriate if those feelings are directed toward us, even if we aren't personally, intentionally, individually responsible for specific instances of this wrongdoing. It would be much easier, much more pleasant, to put all that behind us--not only to expect to be already forgiven, but to expect it to be understood that we don't need to be forgiven, that we have nothing to be forgiven for--and to move on to being friends. We would like to focus on being accepted by each other, on being liked by each other, on being like each other. Instead of doing the hard work of listening, hearing, understanding, we would like people of color to know that we already understand. That we never would have made those mistakes in the first place like our ancestors did, like those other people did. Because we are the cool white people, the woke white people, the nice white people, the innocent white people. We get it. And we hope this will make everything OK again.

The problem with all this is that, of course, it can never make everything OK. Racism and discrimination continue to exist. White privilege is still real. And one of the things that allows these injustices to endure is a persistent refusal by those of us who benefit from them to allow ourselves to be made uncomfortable by acknowledging that benefit, which is the bright dividing line between us, and in which we are complicit. But the line is still there--our refusal to acknowledge it, as with so many things, makes it no less true. Paradoxically, our refusal only highlights the reality of the distance between our experience and the experience of those on the other side of the line. We don't get it. We can't get it, and we won't get it. And the worst thing we could do, under these circumstances, is insist on acting as though we do.

I know all this is difficult to swallow, but if we can make it past the worst of it, there is good news. The good news is, fellow white people, we don't have to get it, we just have to receive it. We need to listen--humbly, and without defensiveness; we need to make our best efforts to understand how our actions have impacted others and continue to do so; we need to take the initiative in finding out how we can be an ally; we need to be open to hearing about our own mistakes. But we cannot gloss over or seek to eradicate our differences by distancing ourselves from our white experience. It's important that we respect the dignity and make room for the voices of people of color, but it is equally important that we own the responsibility and the power of our whiteness. We must be able to see ourselves clearly and come to terms with that truth in order to move forward together honestly and with real humility, not just shame or guilt. The barriers between us can never come down until we learn to accept and appreciate both ourselves and others, just as we are.

Sunday, August 26, 2018

Eyes Off The Ball

So, as you may have heard recently, I missed my son's school registration and failed to get him signed up for his sophomore year of high school. It wasn't just a one-day thing. I missed the entire two-week period of online registration. And when I was done missing that, I missed the day of make-up walk-in registration.

It's not that I wasn't paying attention. I knew he needed to register for school. It's just that I had a lot of other things going on. His older brother was starting college this fall. I was trying to manage housing assignments, book lists, dorm furnishings, parking permits, financial aid, and all the other things that go along with starting that new venture. Plus, on another front, there were all the things involved in moving a child out of your home. The packing. The cleaning. The organizing. For that whole two weeks, it looked like another house threw up inside of my house. And then there are the normal things that go along with starting school for everyone--haircuts, doctor appointments, new glasses, clothes shopping. Every day, high school registration was on my list. And every day, I thought that in another day or another couple of days I would have the time and money to take care of it. And then it was over.

Moms are supposed to be great at multi-tasking, and most of the time we are. One reason, I think, is because we seem to have been gifted with a brain that is laser-focused on everything that needs to be done. You've heard that saying, "Keep your eye on the ball?" Moms are some of the best people I know at keeping our eyes on the ball, even when there is more than one.

But what happens when there are just too many balls in the air? That saying seems like good and necessary advice if you want to hit it out of the park, which is why it's so often used, but let's face it, folks--it's a BASEBALL analogy. And in baseball there is only one ball. I don't know about you, but I have significantly more than one ball in play at any given time.

All the things I listed above are just the extra things that are happening at a snapshot in time. I haven't even addressed all the balls that have to be kept moving every day, just as a part of living. The house, which has to be cleaned, repaired, maintained. The meals that have to be cooked, the groceries that have to be bought, the dishes that have to be washed and dried and put away. The bills that have to be paid, and paid, and paid. The car that needs fuel and insurance and tags and oil changes and new wipers, tires, brakes.

Oh, and then there's work. Just a minor detail.

And while we are doing all this, there are the children, who need more, so much more, than just being housed and clothed and fed. They need someone to encourage them and comfort them. They need opportunities to have and solve problems, to learn how to have strong, healthy relationships, to find their power and their voice as they increasingly step out into the world. They need to be led, launched, listened to. They need to be loved.

So all these balls I have to juggle are not just the trivia and logistics of living, but also the stuff which makes a life. They are the tasks on my to-do list, plus all the things I need to teach, and model, and pass on. And therefore, of course, all the things I need to learn, understand, improve, and heal--all the ways that I myself need to grow. The spinning, flying, rising and dropping balls represent everything I have yet to do and everything I have yet to do better. So where, I ask you, am I supposed to keep my eye?

It's no wonder the school registration ball was dropped.

I don't know if you've ever tried juggling in real life. I have made a couple of half-hearted efforts at it, just for entertainment, and based on them, I can assure you, I'm not a juggler. But I've recently learned from someone who actually possesses this skill what is required to do it successfully. It turns out you have to take your eyes off the ball.

No one, apparently, can actually simultaneously watch that many moving objects. If you try to keep your eye on all of them, monitor them, catch them and release them all at just the right time, you will inevitably lose track of one, then more than one, then try to go back and catch the ones you have lost, and the whole operation will come crashing down and they will fall.

The secret, it seems, is to pick a focal point beyond the balls.

When you focus your eye on a distant point, rather than trying to watch each individual ball, you're able to see the big picture--it lets you pay attention to all the balls at once. You can know where your hands need to be for each one, the perfect time to catch and to release, because you can see them moving together, making up a coordinated whole.

In my life then, with all the many balls that I have in the air, what is the thing I can keep my eyes focused on? 

It can't be the house or the finances or my work. They are still all just balls. It can't even be kids or family or all the people, places, and causes I love, even though those are the things that I live and serve for and that motivate me daily. None of these things are significant enough, beyond enough, to bring order to the whole picture. I am too close to all of them. And "what is essential,"  Antoine de Saint-ExupĂ©ry's Little Prince reminds us, "is invisible to the eye."

Being the Beloved, it turns out, is the focal point.

I've written often in these pages about knowing ourselves as the Beloved of God, and about the writings of theologian Henri Nouwen that expound on this idea as the core truth on which everything turns. I've talked about how understanding this idea will impact all our relationships and all our actions, how it will change the way we see ourselves and all the others in our lives. So it should come as no surprise that it is also the key to the juggling. Knowing you're the Beloved, Henri says, "you can handle an enormous amount of success and an enormous amount of failure." This is true because your acceptance, your value, your Beloved-ness, will never rest on whether you keep all the balls in the air or you drop some. And, strangely, just knowing this will make it easier to keep them in the air. You can forgive yourself (and others) for the failure to love perfectly, or to do perfectly, and just go ahead and love. You can celebrate what matters, and let go of what doesn't. You can focus on being there for others, just being with them; you can stop experiencing them as another thing on your list of things to do. You can even let go of the list from time to time, and just put all those balls down for a minute--if your worth is not measured by your success as a juggler.

In a photo, bringing one object into focus will make the other things fade into the background, blurry and indistinguishable. Focusing on our Beloved-ness will not work that way. Instead of making all the other things unclear and hard to make out, it will let you see them better, more clearly. Looking beyond will sharpen your vision to see things as they really are. You will be able to know where you really need to be, and what you really need to be doing there, what to catch and what to release; you will see the big picture, the coordinated whole. Some balls might still drop. But they will be the ones that did not belong in the first place, the ones that never mattered.

Tomorrow is a Monday, and Mondays are often the hardest day, when all the things I have to do seem to pelt me unmercifully from every direction, demanding to be held and caught, to be coordinated and managed, challenging me to prove my mastery of them or be beaten down to a shameful defeat. I just hope I can remember, even once the onslaught has begun, to keep my eyes off the ball.

Thursday, August 9, 2018

Nerd Night


I know I'm dating myself, but there was a time when being a nerd was not cool.

Some of you are old enough to remember the time I mean. (Some of you may be old enough that you just found out being a nerd is now cool. It's OK. Don't worry. But unfortunately it doesn't apply to us, only to cool, young nerds. It's hard to explain.)

ANYWAY. Back to the time when nerds were lame. My pastor at the time, who was also our youth pastor, told all of us high-schoolers that we were going to have a special event called "Nerd Night". Our instructions were to dress for the occasion, to look as nerdy as possible. The picture above is a bit the worse for wear, but you can see some of us ready to go. As you can tell, my friend and I decided to go retro instead of hard-core nerd, and are wearing some old dresses of my mom's that we scrounged up, with some fairly tacky costume jewelry. Not strictly dorky, but definitely not on fleek. And yes, the biggest nerd there in the middle is Brad, our pastor. I'm guessing there was not a pen left in the church.

Brad came to pick us all up in the church van for Nerd Night. Needless to say, we had never participated in a Nerd Night before, and we didn't know what it might consist of, so we were surprised--and not in a good way--when Brad drove to a local hangout, parked the van, and informed us that we were all going inside, and were going to stay, hang out, and order pizza. Then he got out and went inside.

Easy for him to say, right? At least that's what I was thinking, I don't know about you. He may have had a little bit less to lose by appearing in his nerd getup in front of whichever of our friends and classmates might be inside. It's just possible that it may have taken a few people what seemed like a long time to get out of the van and get inside. In fact, if I were to speculate, I would say that one or two people may have had to make a couple of tries--going all the way to the door only to return to the van and gather courage for a second attempt. It's so difficult, isn't it, especially for teenagers, exposing yourself as vulnerable in front of your peers? Eventually, though, we all made it in.

Once inside, a funny thing happened. At first it was just as you would expect. Mortifying. We shrunk down in our chairs. Glanced surreptitiously around to see if anyone was noticing us. Looked reproachfully at Brad, who was ensuring that we couldn't escape notice, as he employed full Nerd Mode, sitting up as straight as possible with his six-foot-plus frame in the chair and saying loudly to our server, "WE WANT EXTRA DOUGH. CAN WE GET EXTRA DOUGH ON THIS PIZZA?" But you know what? Amazingly, the world didn't come to an end. Maybe some people looked. Maybe they even stared or laughed. But it turns out it wasn't really that big of a deal. In fact, after a bit, it actually started to be....well...fun. Our nerdiness stopped bothering us. We began to embrace it. In fact, in a weird way, we felt kind of proud of it. When we finished eating pizza, we asked Brad if we could go downtown and walk around, and he was only too happy to oblige. We wanted to prolong our Nerd Life--we wanted to see more people and have them see us; we wanted to flaunt the weirdness of our nerdity in the most public space possible. We weren't ready to go home and go back to being normal, non-nerdy teenagers again. (Well, not intentionally nerdy, anyway.)

What we learned was that there was something freeing in it, in this total disregard of the standards we would normally work so hard to observe. The rules of the teenage world often center around striving for mastery of whatever will make us liked, accepted, envied, and looked up to by our peers--and avoiding whatever it is that will cause us to be judged, looked down on, rejected.

The adult world is not so different.

After Nerd Night was over, Brad took us all home, but first, he stopped in the van to talk to us about how the Bible says that we are aliens and strangers on the Earth, how our citizenship is in Heaven. We should not be afraid to be different, he said, because we belong to a different country.

How different it would be, wouldn't it, if we learned to embrace the things that we fear will bring us rejection, judgement, and shame? Our world honors the smart, the strong, the cutting edge, the pulled-together, the always-rising. But what freedom, what joy there could be, I suspect, in no longer being afraid for others to see our weirdness, our brokenness, our imperfections. If only we could know, with the certainty that would set us free, that we belong to a different king, a different country, and in the economy of that kingdom we are valued, treasured, beloved, none the less and all the more for the things we believe we have to bury away. Maybe it would be best if every night was Nerd Night. Maybe if we tried it, we would find that the judgements of others we fear are just that--our own fears, and nothing more. Maybe it's time to try it and see.


Sunday, January 21, 2018

Life in the Hub

"Sometimes I think of life as a big wagon wheel with many spokes.
In the middle is the hub. Often in ministry, it looks like we are
running around the rim trying to reach everybody. But God says,
'Start in the hub; live in the hub. 
Then you will be connected with all the spokes, 
and you won't have to run so fast.'"

~Henri Nouwen, in From Solitude to Community to Ministry


 I don't know about you, but to me, that sure sounds good. Not running so fast. In my ministry to my family, my friends, my co-workers, and the people I actually serve in my work every day, I often feel like I'm running a million miles a minute. There is never enough of anything to go around--not enough time, not enough money, not enough attention, not enough ability--just plain not enough me. I can't make it all the way around the outside of that wheel. And I have been thinking a lot lately about what it looks like, how it would look different, to live in the hub.

It's hard to imagine, and I guess that just proves that maybe I've never been there, in the hub, but I sure know what it looks like here around the outside. It's hard to keep up, and doing so is a full-time job. That means all of the focus has to be on accomplishing the next impossible thing, meeting the next urgent need, leaping the next intimidating hurdle. And the worst thing about the inability to slow down that this creates is that there is never time to take a breath, or to gather your strength, or to say, "Whew! Now that that's finished, what do I need right now?" 

This is largely how I've become the Worst Ever, in the world, at taking care of me. I didn't do it all at once. It took me a lifetime to get there. I know what I need. (That actually puts me ahead of a lot of people, I know.) I need sleep. I need to eat food. Actual, good-tasting, nourishing food, that I eat at regular intervals throughout the day. I need connections with other people that are deep and meaningful and real, and I need tiny indulgences like an extra $3 on something at the store that tells myself from me, "Hey, you are worth this!" and I need time, oh, how I need time--time to think, to read, to write, to plan, to pray. But instead, I stay up late, skip meals, spend more time on work and chores and obligations, worry and stress and find myself too busy or too tired for meaningful connections, and even my time in prayer is simply a chore, another item to be checked off the list. 

I have neglected to prioritize the things that give me life. 

I choose instead to sprint on to the next spoke, always hoping that maybe if I'm just a little faster this time I will make it around. Running around the outside means always dashing to the next place and the next task without stopping, without thinking, without hearing what your body and soul are crying out for.

In the hub, I'd guess you stand still.

Around the outside, there's not a moment to spare.

In the hub, there's no hurry.

The last few months have been a time for me to think a lot about that--about how I can walk right down one of those spokes to the middle, and about what changes I would need to make to do that. Tonight, forcing myself to take the scheduled time to sit, read, think, and rest that I put on my calendar a couple of months ago, I opened up to these words:

"He will be like a tree firmly planted by streams of water,
Which yields its fruit in its season,
And its leaf does not wither;
And in whatever he does, he prospers."    ~Psalm 1:3
  
I thought about what it means to prosper--the dictionary says, "to become strong and flourishing; to thrive." I've heard this passage so many times, but it's amazing how different things can sound when you slow down. How I needed to hear those words tonight, to see this picture. The roots drinking deeply from that slow, continuous stream of life-giving nourishment. The fruit appearing slowly, seasonally, in its own good time. The tree that experiences and is touched by everything around it, but is not shaken or moved from its base, and is never deterred from its primary task-- to grow. Thrive. Bloom. Bear. Rest. 

Oh, how I hope I am learning to be like that tree, and how I hope I am leading my sons this way too, leading them to the hub where I am slowly learning to find grace, peace, rest; and may they reach it sooner than me, because it is taking me a lifetime to get there.


Sunday, August 13, 2017

In The Shadow Of The Giving Tree


Lately, I've been doing some difficult thinking about why relationships fail. Now, we all know why some relationships fail. For better or worse, it is simply true that some relationships are ill-advised, ill-executed, and ill-fated from the beginning, for a variety of reasons. But there are others, relationships between people who are seemingly mature, emotionally capable, strong and stable, who have a good foundation and a high capacity for love, and I think we are all more puzzled when these types of relationships don't succeed in the long-term, both for those we know, and even for ourselves. Honestly, some of the divorces I know have shocked me to my core, and none more than my own. And an over-analyzer like me has to stop and wonder--is there a common theme? A reason that is more than just individual circumstance, why so many seemingly solid relationships eventually founder and fall?

Obviously, I don't have the answer. But there is something I've observed that is at least common to many of the relationships that are close to me, and I believe it is relevant to many more. It goes back to something I have spoken and written about many times, both here on this blog and elsewhere, a thought from theologian Henri Nouwen, about how the identity of every human is as the Beloved of God. I've mentioned before that Nouwen even goes so far as to call this the "core truth of our existence".

In his powerful essay "From Solitude to Community to Ministry", Nouwen says that being able to hear the voice that calls us Beloved comes from practicing the discipline of solitude. (If you haven't read this essay, by the way, please do. I don't care who you are, or whether you believe all this God stuff or not, just take a few minutes. I think you need this in your life.) Solitude, Nouwen says, does not equal loneliness; knowing yourself as the Beloved is solitude, holding that knowledge at your core, not needing to have it supplied from an outside source. Holding onto that truth, listening to that voice before all others, is what enables us to enter into community, into relationships with others, without having to expect others to provide this for us. Rather than loneliness grabbing onto loneliness, for those of us who truly know ourselves as the Beloved--in the center of our being, our guts, resounding through our whole being, he says--we can enter a relationship prepared to give without reservation, without expectation, without keeping score. We will be giving out of our overflow. We will be able to forgive others for not loving us perfectly, unconditionally. We will not need them to do this for us, because we are filled up inside, in all the places that matter, with the knowledge that we are God's Beloved daughter or son, that no matter where we have been or what we have done, we remain in His favor.

NOT knowing yourself as the Beloved, however, is a vacuum inside.

In the well-known children's book The Giving Tree, author Shel Silverstein tells us the story of a tree who loves a little boy, and as the Boy grows up through every stage of life, the Tree is there to give whatever the boy needs. The Tree, deeply rooted, drawing its sustenance from deep within, has much to give, and is made happy by loving the Boy, and by seeing him happy. The Boy, however, is always roaming, looking for fulfillment in first one thing and then another--at first finding it in the simple pleasure of being with the Tree, but when this proves inadequate, seeking it in young love, then a house of his own, then a wife and family, and at every turn coming back to the tree in sadness and dissatisfaction, asking always for the next thing he believes will fill the void. In the end, after the Tree has given everything--its leaves, fruit, branches, and even its trunk--and has nothing left to offer, the Boy returns as an old man, looking only for a place to sit and rest, and sits down, satisfied, on the withered stump that remains.

This story is often lauded as an example, a model of selfless giving to be emulated, which I don't believe it to be. Yet even if the ending of this tale was a desirable outcome for both Tree and Boy, in my experience, this cannot be how the story ends in life. Every time, I am surprised that the Boy-turned-man does not douse the stump with gasoline and set it alight, crying out over the crackling flames in his pain and emptiness, "I need wood to make my cane! YOU NEVER LOVED ME!" Because a person who needs a partner to fill them up can never be satisfied; this is not work that can be done from the outside. The Tree will give and give until it is nothing but an old, barren stump, this much is true--but even then, the Boy will never truly feel loved until he knows he is Beloved, and this is not something that can be given to him by another.

So on this the relationship founders, and ultimately falls. One who does not know himself as the Beloved can never forgive our failure to love him perfectly. And there is much--so, so much--to forgive, since none of us, no matter how well-equipped to love, can ever love perfectly. And every one of our many failures to do so is seen by our loved one, that unknowing Beloved, as a rejection, an insult, an abandonment, a wound. Our failure to love him as he deserves is a failure to confirm that he is worthy of love.

As a result, every action of our unknowing Beloved in the relationship can be justified by this, our failure to love adequately. To me, the most poignant and true moment in the Giving Tree story is when the Boy comes to ask of the Tree nothing but wood to make a boat "that will take me away from here", demanding the Tree itself to help him find happiness far away. After all, when we fall short of what is needed, what is left for our loved one to do for their pain but punish us with silence, treat us abusively, seek better comfort in the arms of another lover, a companion, a friend, or a find a new life far away? We were those who were supposed to LOVE them, love them in the way they most deeply needed, that affirmed their worthiness of love and belonging, in the way that made them truly know themselves as Beloved. And we accepted this--this awesome, terrible, impossible responsibility. But there is only One who can call us Beloved, so in doing so, in taking this responsibility that was never ours, we have made a terrible mistake, one with the most serious consequences for both us and the ones we love.

On the front flap of the book cover on my copy of The Giving Tree, the publisher describes the role of the Tree in the story as "a serene acceptance of another's capacity to love in return".  And perhaps this is where the trouble lies. As we enter into relationships with others, do we look for solitude that can join with solitude? Or do we blithely attempt to create in ourselves the solution to another's loneliness? Are we drawing, always, back to the only one who calls us all Beloved, inviting others to join the Beloved community? Or do we rush into the breach, giving, giving, giving, leaving nothing but a withered, barren stump of ourselves, the memory of Beloved community only a wisp of smoke in our wake, serenely accepting our loved ones' inability to give in return, bereft of the knowledge of themselves as Beloved like us? We have contributed to our own downfall--to ours, and to theirs. It's time to stop. For ourselves, and for the ones we love, we must find the strength to swallow our pride, embrace the limits of our purpose, step out of the shadow of the Giving Tree, and into the surrender of community as it's meant to be. Only then, as Nouwen says, can we create space in which God can act and speak; and then, he assures us, something surprising will happen. In our total surrender, he tells us, God will act to make us, not accomplished, but fruitful, as He acts through us to call others back to Himself. And in the end, only that will make our joy complete.

Thursday, October 13, 2016

That's Just Perfect



This OCD joke is everywhere now--mugs, memes, t-shirts, and even on an embroidered pillow I saw--but the first time I encountered it was at least 10 years ago, before all that, when it was a cartoon in Reader's Digest. A friend of mine, waiting in the dentist's office, read it, and told me later, "I saw this--it made me think of you!" I guess maybe it was because she had been present to see the look on another friend's face when, on an earlier occasion, they were browsing through my recipe box, and the second friend suddenly asked in consternation, "Wait. Are these in alphabetical order?"

OK, so I have a bit of a reputation. I like things a certain way. The right way.

I like to think of myself as a "recovering perfectionist", however. I hope I'm getting better. After all, I only spent *cough numberofminutes cough* looking for a version of this meme with proper punctuation! Seriously, though, I admit that the siren song of perfectionism has always held a certain lure for me. There is something so appealing about the idea of doing everything perfectly right. And perfectionism, although a futile pursuit, is one that our culture affirms and even idolizes.

Sometimes I think that those of us who are prone to perfectionism tend to think that the only thing wrong with the desire to be perfect is that it's impossible. We all know we can never get there, and that trying will ultimately prove futile. But the truth is, I think it doesn't even matter that perfection is impossible to attain, because even if we could accomplish it, I think we'd find that the accomplishment would let us down. Here's why.

1.  Perfect doesn't touch what we need it to touch.

When we think about being perfect, we have the idea that it means always being right, and always doing right. But in actual fact, to be truly perfect requires something different. Real perfection is not about "rightness"--moral self-improvement. That kind of perfection is actually a lowering of standards, because it's only superficial; it's on the outside. Real perfection would be through and through. In order to be truly perfect, we would need something to touch much deeper--to perfect our hearts, our souls. To make us patient, kind, joyful, humble, forgiving, unselfish. We would need not only to be right, but to be good.

Our real struggle for perfection, then, is over the primacy of self. Removing ourselves from the place of greatest importance is the only path to genuine goodness of heart. And, in a supreme irony, this is the one act that perfectionism will never allow us, because at its heart, perfectionism is all about self. The relentless pursuit of our desire to justify ourselves by our own means, through our own efforts, will yield nothing but an obsession with ourselves and our own outward appearance.

2.  Perfect can't grow what we want it to grow.

But what if I'm mistaken? What if we can achieve goodness through striving for perfection? People smarter than I have certainly thought so. Benjamin Franklin, for example, went to great lengths to record his detailed plan for mastering 13 essential virtues of the heart, including humility. However, I think on deeper examination, we have to acknowledge that even Franklin had to accomplish his plan through trial and error--and it turned out to be a lot of error. In fact, if you read Franklin's journal, you'll find that one of the primary things he learned during his attempt was finding himself "so much fuller of faults than I had imagined", and that is a very important piece of discovery. And in the end, not only does Franklin conclude that it is impossible for him to reach the perfection of virtue he has been striving for, but that, with regard to the problem of pride in particular, "even if I could conceive that I had completely overcome it, I should probably be proud of my humility."

So we see that even if we look deeper, past external self-improvement, to a higher standard or different definition of perfection, the virtues we then value can't be developed through a self-focused act of the will. We might, as Franklin says he did, make some improvement in the mastering the appearance of them, but not the substance. Patience, humility, perseverance, resilience, grace--all these are traits borne of suffering, trials, discomfort, surprise. In order to really grow and change, we have to mess things up, make fools of ourselves, fall down and get back up. We can't become the person we envision without making mistakes. True perfection--or the closest thing we can reach--is only arrived at through the experience of our own imperfection.

3.  Perfect won't do what we want it to do.

But why do we really want to be perfect anyway? I think it's because the idea of perfection isn't appealing only as an end in itself--its attraction is in what we think it will do for us. Deep down, we somehow believe that if we just do everything right, we can somehow make everything else go right too. Perfectionism is an effort to gain control, over ourselves and over our circumstances. If we can just do everything exactly right, we can make sure of the outcomes for the people, interactions, situations, and relationships that make up our lives. Things will always go the way we hope. Certainly, at least, no one will ever be able to look down on us, criticize us, be angry with us, or dislike us if we are perfect. Being perfect will make us good enough, in our own eyes and in the eyes of others. In other words, we believe that our perfection will protect both our loved ones and ourselves from the unexpected, the undesirable, and from failure, pain, and rejection.

The unfortunate truth is that perfection can't cause any of this to happen, or keep any of it from happening. Life is unpredictable, and the world is sometimes a painful and scary place. Bad things happen. They happen to us, and to the people we love. Sometimes this is because we make mistakes, but not always. Sometimes it's because other people make mistakes. And sometimes it's just the way the world is. It's broken, and we can never fix it all on our own. We can only do our best, and even then, even if our best was perfect, it is no guarantee that things will go right, or that others will love us, accept us, or approve of us. As long as we live as broken people in a broken world, there will be tragedy and loss--we will hurt each other, and things that no one understands will sometimes happen. No matter how perfect we are, nothing can change this.

So what can we say then? If the pursuit of perfection is empty, what good can we take away? I think there is still something. The beauty in the complete barrenness, the empty promise that is perfectionism, is that it reminds us who we are. We are the Beloved. And as the Beloved, it is not our job to do any of the things we have tried to accomplish through our own perfection. We cannot save ourselves from pain, failure, or loss; we cannot make ourselves loved, accepted, respected; we cannot ensure that everything in our world will go right; and we do not have to. We were not created for this purpose. As the Beloved, we were created to be loved. And so we are. We need do nothing to earn it, and nothing that we or anyone else can do, say, or think, can change it. Our value is secure--our welfare is assured. Perfection can never offer us either.

Friday, September 23, 2016

Turn It Down

 
I don't know about you, but sometimes, I feel like nobody's listening to me. I talk to my kids--or at least I try--but it seems nothing's getting through.

"Are you even listening to me?"

"Am I talking to myself?"

"Have you heard one word I've said?"

"Hellooo! You!"

"Is my voice invisible?"
 
Now that I have teenagers, the most common scenario (and my least favorite) is the one where I try to get their attention but they have headphones on or earbuds in. This one often starts with my talking to them from the other room, so I don't realize they have any reason other than the usual for not answering, when I say something that requires a response.
 
I get no answer, so I say it again, this time louder.
 
Still nothing. The third time I don't want to waste my breath saying the whole thing over, so I just call out their name.
 
No answer. Now I have stopped whatever I was doing, I'm on my way to find them and figure out what the problem is, and I'm on the fourth attempt to get their attention, so it's easy to call their name pretty loud. It's also pretty easy to tell that I'm annoyed.

Getting within view and spotting the offending headphones doesn't dispel any of the annoyance, but it does make me call them even louder the next time. By this time I'm usually standing almost right next to them. Aaand I'm pretty much shouting. Even then I still often have to do it more than once. And finally, about the time I get to THIS LEVEL OF FRUSTRATION AND VOLUME, they turn around, pull off the headphones, and say, in an offended and angry tone, "WHAT!" 
 
Because I'm yelling at them. They don't like yelling.

Actually, I don't like yelling either. I don't like yelling, and I don't like being yelled at. Honestly, I don't like it when someone is angry with me, period. And I especially don't like it when they are angry with me for being The Yelling Mom, when I feel it's hardly my fault that it takes 8 minutes and a brass band to get their attention.

This isn't the only time this happens, of course. There are other times when they think I am Yelling Mom. For example, any day that I straggle home exhausted from work to find chores undone, trash everywhere, dirty dishes galore, and them in front of video games, I am that mom. And every time, they are angry.

Why do I have to yell at them? Why do I have to keep telling them what they're doing wrong? Why am I interrupting them right when they were about to win? Why do I always have to be so mad??

I get it. Nobody likes to have their fun interrupted by an unpleasant reminder of how they have messed up, or how that mess-up has disappointed, hurt, or angered someone else. A reminder delivered by the disappointed, hurt, and angry someone is even more unpleasant. But the conversation we keep having is, can they expect anything else? If they ignore me when I speak or give directions, if they choose not to take responsibility, if they disregard basic rules of conduct for the household, isn't it reasonable to assume that I will not be happy? And when this happens, guess what? You don't get to be angry about it. Mom's displeasure is a logical and expected result of your actions. 

Right now, every day, as I watch TV or read Facebook, I see this same dynamic being played out all around us, on the stage of race relations in this country. And there is something I want to say to those of us in the white community.

I get it. It's not pleasant to hear about the wrongs that have been done to others on our watch, and it's especially unpleasant to contemplate our own responsibility in them, even if our complicity is simply our own obliviousness. It's tempting to avoid doing so by taking issue with the way the message is being delivered. But friends, please realize what's happening--we have had the headphones on.

We have had the headphones on, and it is time now--time to turn down the music of our own comfortable narrative, and listen to what our brothers and sisters of color have been trying, repeatedly, over many long years, to get our attention to tell us. Time to stop being angry about the tone of voice or the choice of words or the forum used to communicate the message, and take the time to understand the hurt, anger, and frustration that is a result of not only others', but our own actions. Time to stop dictating to people of color the ways that are acceptable to us for them to express their responses to our behavior. We just simply haven't been listening, not for a long, long, time. It's time to start.

Sunday, August 28, 2016

For the Single Moms

I admit, right up front, I am far from an expert at the single mom thing. For one thing, I have only been a single parent for four years, which is a blink of the eye compared with many of my friends who have raised their children alone, maybe even from the beginning, and are still going strong all these years later. Also, my kids do have a dad in their lives, so, unlike many moms I know who are truly going it alone, I do have someone who shares some of the cost and time involved in raising kids, and is invested in their safety and welfare. All of which is to say, I know that there are many mothers out there whose strength, tenacity, courage, and endurance I have not been called upon to match, and I'm sure any one of them is better suited to share these thoughts than I. But since I am all I've got right now, I intend to give it a shot anyway. I've learned a lot in these last four years--here is what I want to tell you, all of you, the single moms who are my friends, companions, support group, inspiration, and sanity, as we walk this path together.

1. You can do it. 
Seriously. You can. I know, I know, my texts say otherwise. They say, "I can't do this," and "Seriously. I can't," and "Please come and get them, someone else should do this." But don't listen to the texts. They are sent in moments of duress, they don't mean anything. We all have those moments. Right? (We do all have those, right? That's not just me, right?)

Believe me now when I tell you, in this (reasonably) sane moment, that you are so much stronger and better than you think, and you can do the things your kids need from you. It's so hard sometimes, I know, to take the high road. It's hard to make the choices that are in their best interests when those don't always coincide with the choices that are in ours. It's hard to act intentionally rather than react emotionally. It's hard not to come home at the end of a long day and yell, because there are dishes everywhere, and they were supposed to start the laundry but they "forgot", and no one but you has EVER emptied an ice cube tray, and after all, we can't do everything ourselves. It's hard to remember in that moment that they couldn't possibly understand the weight, and that we wouldn't really want them to--hard to remind ourselves that it isn't their fault that we are the only ones, and they are children, just children. It's hard to do the full-time day at work and the full-time night at home and the all-the-time activities at the school, and still listen politely, through bone-deep exhaustion, as a part-time parent talks about how difficult things are. It's hard to bite our tongue and swallow our tears and wave them out the door and say only, "Have a good birthday!" or "Have fun!" on Christmas Eve. It's hard to have them so close, every second of every minute of every day, and it's hard--so, so hard--to let them go.

But one thing I know is that when it comes to them, you can do anything. You have made it this far, and everything you have done and are doing is for them. Maybe even the reason you are doing it on your own is because of them. And you have an untold reservoir of strength that even you do not know the depths of, and you will draw on it when the moment comes, and you will not be disappointed with what you find. You may stumble, and you may fall, and it may not feel like it, but I promise--you can do this.

Except when you can't. Because....

2. Sometimes, you just can't.
Honestly, there are things that are just beyond one person's capacity to bear. There is only so much of us to go around. There won't be time, money, energy, or emotion to spare for everything--it's just not possible. Check the homework folder? Nope. Return email? Uh-uh. Clean up this atrocious mess? That would mean I'd have to get up off the couch. Sometimes we just can't go to one more track meet. NOT. ONE. MORE. Sometimes we have to say no to things, things we once did or always wanted to do, things that are important to us or to the kids. Sometimes we have to sit down and have a family meeting to decide that there will be no more cooking dinner--ever--because we just can't do it anymore. (Completely hypothetical. Never happened.) (OK, fine. That one's real.) Sometimes we simply cannot listen to one more second of conversation about the most amazing fun and awesome family game night at Dad's, or force ourselves to smilingly accept the warm, homemade, organic, fresh-baked, chocolate oatmeal cookie from the new woman in our kids' (and ex's) lives. We just can't. We can't even.

But here's the thing. And listen carefully, because this part is important. That's OK.  That's been hard for me to get to, but there has never been a time when it wasn't true. Your kids don't need you to be invincible. They don't need you to be perfect. In fact, they need to know that you sometimes can't. They need to know that you need their help. They need to know that you feel the hurt and pain in your lives together, just like they do--that you are all in it together. They need to know that you sometimes get sad, tired, and angry, sometimes make mistakes, that you are human, just like them and just like everyone else, and that these things are survivable. You are doing more for them by modeling healing, grace, and resilience in the face of all you cannot do, than you ever could by making them think there is nothing you cannot do. One of the most important things they will ever learn in life is that true strength comes only from acknowledging our own weakness--if all they see in us is an unattainable perfection, how will they not simply become discouraged and give up when, inevitably, there comes a time when they just cannot? 

So when you're at the end of your rope, just tie a knot and hang on, because even then, especially then, you are doing what you need to do for them. And, most importantly of all...

3. You are enough.
I know it will never be possible to do everything for them. We can't take away the events of the past. We can't get them all the things we will never afford. We can't give them the father or the family we always hoped they would have. No matter how much time and attention we had to offer them, it would always be possible to find a way that we could do more, give more. But right now, we are giving them the thing they need from us the most, which is ourselves. We are giving all we have, and that is not only sufficient but is actually abundant--many others have so much less. Even though it feels as though there is never enough time, never enough energy, never enough money or resources or sleep to go around, we are doing it, friends, and we have got this. Even when we haven't.

You are enough, just the way you are. You're all the mom they need.

Tuesday, April 19, 2016

Nothing But the Truth




I've always felt, for some reason, ever since I was a child, a pressure to answer any question that was put to me, as accurately, truthfully, and correctly as possible. Unfortunately, sometimes accuracy, truth, and "correctness" have been in conflict with each other. When that happens, I have never known what to do. My seventh-grade science teacher said to me, with a pained sigh, "Lisa. Just go back to your desk, and mark. true. or. false." 

I am caught between all my felt obligations--to give the questioner the answer they are looking for (correctness), the actual facts of the situation (accuracy), and the real heart of the matter (truth). I try hard--often too hard--to reconcile all three, to package the truth together with the facts and make it fit in the correct box. But sometimes there just doesn't seem to be any box that will hold the answer that is true.

Nowhere have I felt this more keenly over recent years than when it comes to my divorce.

When bad things happen, it's only natural that people have a lot of questions. Painful things are hard. They are scary, and not just for the person they have happened to. We are afraid, and we need answers. Sometimes, we look for the answers that will comfort us in doctrine, research, or teaching. Sometimes we simply find them in our own opinions. Sometimes we look to the person who has been most affected, to tell their story, to supply the facts. Knowing the answers lets us feel like we can make sense of it all, like we have it figured out--even that we can protect ourselves from suffering the same outcome.

The questions I've experienced surrounding my divorce have come from all of these places. They've sometimes been asked as questions, and sometimes been expressed as certainties, but even when they are made as pronouncements of fact, there is still a query behind them that is directed with expectation at me. Which answer box does my situation fit in?

Was the divorce my fault? Was it his fault? Which one of us divorced the other? Was it because of an affair? Maybe even one of those dreaded "emotional affairs" we are so fond of warning about? Was it because we thought we could just give up when the going got tough--because we didn't remove "divorce" from our vocabulary? FOR THE LOVE OF GOD, DID WE LET THE SUN GO DOWN ON OUR ANGER??

"Teacher, was it this man who sinned, or his parents, that he was born blind?" 

We know these are the possible correct answers. Please choose one. We are waiting.

The problem is, I am being asked a question that I can't answer. Not because I don't know the answer. No. I know. In fact, I am the expert. I know every detail, every moment, every memory and scar. I can't answer because it's an impossible question, it's a trick question. No one could answer it.

I didn't get divorced because I wasn't open to reconciliation, or because I didn't pray the Scriptures for my husband, or because it was never a true Christian marriage to begin with. (All of which, in case you are wondering, have actually been said to me.) I didn't get divorced because I knew someone else who got divorced, even though statistics show that people are much more likely to get divorced if they know someone who has, because seeing others who just give up when things get difficult can make you think it's an easy option to give up too. (Yes, also said to me.) I wasn't just unhappy with my husband and decided to get rid of him--in doing so, by the way, making a friend who is currently struggling in marriage think that maybe she can do the same. (Yep. This one too. Not by the friend, of course.)

I know this isn't what people want to hear, but the truth at the heart of my divorce will not fit into any of these preconceived theological certainties. You won't find the answer to it in any article with five easy tips for keeping your marriage happy, or five terrible mistakes to avoid. No marriage class or seminar would have fixed it. Please understand, if any of these things have been valuable to you or are relevant to your experience, I am not dismissing that. I am speaking only of my own situation. The sweeping generalities are part of the problem. But my story, my counselor tells me, only I will truly know, and that will have to be enough, both for you and for me.

So people. Christians. Friends and acquaintances, brothers and sisters, family. We have come from the same place, you and I; we've walked the same, familiar spiritual path, and I understand. I know that not one of you means me any harm. I'm sure that most of you, if you are aware of having had these questions for me at all, stopped asking them long ago, and do not even realize that I am still struggling to answer them, every time I hear you talk about marriage, divorce, and relationships. I'm just learning, myself, how much I still feel the pressure to answer correctly, in a way that will satisfy you, and I know that much of that pressure is coming from no one but myself. I do love you, and I believe we have a responsibility to each other.  I believe we are accountable to each other. I do. Nevertheless, I am finally coming to know, probably too late in life, that sometimes the problem is not with the answer. Sometimes it is with the question. And I have reached a point where the effort of trying to make the truth fit into one of the boxes is tying me in knots. It is hindering my forward motion. There's a problem with the question, and it's time I stopped trying to answer it. It's time, as my counselor says, for me to learn to honor my narrative, not to defend it. It's time to tell myself, and everyone else, the truth. The truth is, it's a bullshit question. It's as simple as that.

Friday, December 25, 2015

Mother of All Christmases

This year, it is not my turn to spend Christmas with my kids.  According to a very fair and well-regulated co-parenting agreement, the celebration of this holiday alternates from year to year between parental households.  (This year, I had Thanksgiving.)  They left yesterday morning with their dad, his wife, and her daughter, to spend four days with their grandparents out of state, and they'll be back on Sunday.

This isn't the first time I'll be spending Christmas without them--it's the second, actually.  This time is different, though, because this year is the first Christmas that will be shared with a step-family.  As the central point of coordination for gift-giving, I've been surprised and a bit alarmed at the flood of emails, inundating me with lists of gift after gift that will be purchased for them by brand new family members, eager to welcome them with open arms.

Each year of the last four has presented a new set of challenges, a new uncertain territory for my family.  And somehow, the holiday season often seems to be the time when the highest of these hurdles are presented.  This Christmas season, as I release my little ones (not so little any more) into the care of others, I have been thinking a lot about that other mother, that famous Christmas mother, Mary.

We Protestants don't like to talk a lot about Mary, lest someone get the wrong idea.  But I think it's possible that Mary has some things she could tell me, and I'd like to hear what she could say--as it's said in Home Alone, "from a mother, to a mother".

I think about how it must have been, as a mother, to release the man that was still your baby, not just to another parent or another family, but to the whole rest of the world.  So many other mothers, sisters, brothers, and miscellaneous claimants on his time, his attention, his life.  It didn't just seem like there were hordes of people trying to claim him.  There were hordes of people trying to claim him, some out of genuine love and devotion, but many for their own purposes, with their own agendas.  His relationship with each of them would be part of his own story, and part of theirs, but not part of hers--she could only look on, with a heart full of hope and fear.

I think about how puzzling, how impossible, it must have seemed, sometimes, to hold on to her confidence in the promise of his destiny.  Her job, her mission, was to nurture him to readiness for his part in a plan she could not know, see, or understand.  So many people, events, and influences lay outside her control. I wonder how many times it seemed to her as if something must have gone horribly wrong.  I think surely she must have second-guessed herself when things appeared at their worst--was this how things were supposed to be?  And if not, was it her fault?  Had she failed him, failed her task, failed God?

I might be wrong, but I think maybe she worried a little, just like me.  Maybe she even cried sometimes.  Maybe her text history would have looked something like mine:

I can't do this.  I'm serious this time.
They need someone else.  I'm just not up to it.
What am I doing wrong?

I know our situations are not the same.  Obviously, she had a lot more at stake than I do.  But to every mother, our own dear ones are The Ones.  And for all of us, the lesson is the same.  They belong to us, but they are not ours to keep.  They have their own story to live, they are part of a larger plan that we cannot know or understand.  There may be a path before them that is longer, harder than we would desire (and possibly greater than we could guess), but there is only One who can direct it.  We can try with all our might to remember to be grateful that they have been entrusted to us for a season.  We can look on, with fear and trembling, with joy and pride, and with unfailing hope; we can be there from beginning to end, every time they look back, fall down, or take off and fly.  But ultimately, stumble or fly they must.  And no matter how painful, confusing, scary, or downright crazy-making it might be, Mary, that other mother, with her heart both full and broken by her baby boy who was Emmanuel himself, tells me--hang on.  It will be all right.


Thursday, September 17, 2015

Why I Can't Even

Actual Conversations From My House This Week

"Can I have the Coke?"
It's too late for you to drink a Coke tonight, but you can save it for later.
"Can I take it to school tomorrow?"
No, you may not.
"FINE!"

"I packed a lunch."
What's in it?
(The lunchbox is opened to reveal two bags of Cheetos.)
No.  That is not lunch.
"But I put some grapes in there!"
Nope.  Still no.
"FINE!"

"Can I have a hot dog bun?"
No.
"But why can't I have one?  Why?  WHY?"
Because the hot dog buns are for hot dogs.  And you have five minutes to brush your teeth, comb your hair, feed the cat, and get your stuff together for school,which is what you're supposed to be doing.
"FINE!"

"Mom, I'm out of socks."
What do you mean, out of socks?
"I'm out.  There aren't even any in the laundry.  I don't have any more."
But...(sigh).  OK.

"There's no bread.  We don't even have any bread, and it's all [brother's name]'s fault!  He eats all the bread!  I HATE [BROTHER'S NAME]!  AND I CAN'T WAIT UNTIL HE GETS DOWN HERE SO I CAN TELL HIM SO!!"

I'm thinking of staying home with you guys tonight instead of going to my meeting.
"I don't think so.  I think you should consider the future of your job."
That doesn't have anything to do with this.  I was just thinking it might be good for us to spend an evening together at home.
"Well...the thing is, I thought you were going to be at a meeting.  And I already made plans for tonight.  And if you stay home, you'll probably want us to do something.  You know, like spend time talking.  Or eat together."
(#winning)

Go to bed.
"Mom, can I join the debate team?"
I don't know.  Because I have no idea what's involved in joining the debate team.  So you'll need to bring me some more information before I can answer that question.
"Hmm.  I wonder if we have a debate team."
OH, FOR THE--GO TO BED!!

"Oh, Mom, we forgot to tell you, the toilet overflowed today.  Don't worry--we fixed it."

I feel like we haven't had a conversation in three days that wasn't an argument.
"Yes we have.  We had one earlier, in the car."

If you don't lie down and be quiet and go to sleep now, my next plan is to knock you unconscious with a blunt instrument.

Sunday, August 23, 2015

Top 7 Reasons Why I Completely Trust the Government With My Life, My Future, and the Education of My Children (Not)

 
1.  The multiple postcards I've received about my health care coverage that read, "We are about to mail you information regarding some very important upcoming changes to your medical card. If this is not your correct address, please notify us immediately, as it is very important that you receive this information."

2.  This nonsense right here.

3.  Which is the logical equivalent of this further nonsense.  (Livin' the dream!)

4.  The fact that free, government-issued cell phones are the only phones that won't work with 211, a service of the United Way that provides information about community resources to low-income families.  You know.  The families with the free government-issued cell phones.

5.  No Child Left Behind, and all its crack-smoking cousins.  (Don't think it belongs on this list?  I beg to differ.)

6.  Current presidential candidate (Insert name here--it doesn't matter which one.)

7.

Wednesday, May 27, 2015

Lisa's Spring Clean in 30

This household's version of Clean Mama's "Spring Clean in 30 Challenge".  (Clean Mama's originals are listed for purposes of comparison.)

Clean Mama                                                 This Mama
1.  Dust edges/corners at ceiling          1.  Use broom to swipe down
                                                                        huge cobwebs from corners
                                                                        at ceiling.
2.  Dust edges/corners at ground         2.  Repeat process with cobwebs
                                                                         in lower corners.
3.  Clean vents & change filters            3.  Peer in vents.  Cobwebs too
                                                                         many for even the broom.  Debate
                                                                         and decide against rescuing
                                                                         multiple trapped Nerf darts.
                                                                         Go with God, Nerf darts.
4.  Vacuum edges-baseboards               4.  Run broom along baseboards.
                                                                         Heavy coating of cobwebs is
                                                                         effective in picking up dust.
5.  Wash baseboards                               5.  Whaa?  That's not even a thing.
6.  Clean front & back door                   6.  Look at front & back doors.  They
                                                                         look pretty good.
7.  Wipe door knobs & doors                 7.  Wipe knobs with antibacterial wipe.
8.  Wipe switch plates                            8.  Wipe exactly 6 switch plates.
                                                                           Calculate number of switch plates
                                                                           left, including how many must be
                                                                           reached by climbing stairs.  6 is
                                                                           good percentage.
9.  Dust light fixtures                              9.  Dust single lamp that is within
                                                                           reach. Light fixtures are high.
10.  Freshen disposal & drains             10.  Dig slimy cereal from this morning
                                                                           out of drain; hack hardened bits
                                                                           off surface of sink.
11.  Dust ceiling fans                             11.  Get stepladder and dust ceiling fans.
12.  Clean refrigerator & freezer          12.  Look in refrigerator.  Throw away
                                                                           petrified fruit. Pour half-full jar of
                                                                           spaghetti sauce topped with blue
                                                                           fuzz down cereal-free drain.  Open
                                                                           freezer and look around.  Take out
                                                                           nearly-empty carton of ice cream
                                                                           and eat the rest to celebrate
                                                                           successfully dusting ceiling fans.
13.  Clean oven & microwave             13.  Start oven self-cleaning cycle.
                                                                          Scrape, scrub, and smear a layer of
                                                                          unidentifiable goop off all four
                                                                          sides of microwave using
                                                                           "microwave cleaning wipe".
                                                                          Repeat until fingertips begin
                                                                          pruning.
14.  Clear & clean kitchen counters   14.  Clear counter of most of the heaps
                                                                          of toast crumbs and the largest
                                                                          smears of Nutella
15.  Couches/chairs/slipcovers           15.  Move stacks of papers, dirty
                                                                          dishes, unopened mail, socks,
                                                                          Nerf, devices & accessories, to
                                                                          create empty space on the couch.
                                                                          Sit. Think about what to do next.
16.  Kitchen cupboards & drawers    16.  Visualize rearranging kitchen
                                                                          cabinets.  Realize you have
                                                                          accidentally dozed off when you
                                                                          begin assigning organizing jobs
                                                                          to the woodland creatures who
                                                                          are assisting you.  Wake up.
                                                                          Reluctantly.
17.  Clean washer & dryer                     17.  It's the washer.  It washes things.
18.  Wash windows and mirrors           18.  Windows?  What windows?
                                                                          Clean mirrors with Windex
                                                                          wipes.  Virtually no cleaning
                                                                          job they do not now make a
                                                                          "wipe" for.
19.  Wash window sills                           19.   Hilarious.      
20.  Vacuum mattresses & rotate         20.  Sit down again briefly to
                                                                           recover from incapacitating
                                                                           hysterical laughter episode.
21.  Clean bathtubs & showers             21.  Decide to regain strength
                                                                           from Dr. Phil while making
                                                                           kids clean bathtub/shower.
22.  Bathroom counters, sinks,             22.  Yell at kids from couch to
        and toilets                                                   do the sinks and toilets too.
23.  Bath mats & shower curtains        23.  Throw bath mat in trash.
                                                                           New one at Walmart is $5.
                                                                           What are you supposed to
                                                                           do with shower curtain??
24.  Dust all hard surfaces                   24.  Dust the surfaces.  They
                                                                           make a wipe for this.
25.  Wash bedding                                 25.  Look at kids' beds.
                                                                           Bedding completely
                                                                           inaccessible, since they
                                                                           sleep, as your mother says,
                                                                           "like a homeless person".
                                                                           Put your own bedding in
                                                                           washer.
26.  Wash curtains and drapes           26.  This is why we don't
                                                                           have curtains or drapes.
27.  Clean window blinds                     27.  Nope.
28.  Vacuum all floors and stairs       28.  Vacuum floors.  Would
                                                                            not vacuum stairs for all
                                                                            the tea in China.
29.  Wash all floors                            29.  PEOPLE.  SWIFFER
                                                                            MAKES A WIPE
                                                                           FOR THIS.
30.  Deep clean vacuum cleaner      30.  THIS. IS. NOT. A. THING.