Thursday, October 13, 2016

That's Just Perfect



This OCD joke is everywhere now--mugs, memes, t-shirts, and even on an embroidered pillow I saw--but the first time I encountered it was at least 10 years ago, before all that, when it was a cartoon in Reader's Digest. A friend of mine, waiting in the dentist's office, read it, and told me later, "I saw this--it made me think of you!" I guess maybe it was because she had been present to see the look on another friend's face when, on an earlier occasion, they were browsing through my recipe box, and the second friend suddenly asked in consternation, "Wait. Are these in alphabetical order?"

OK, so I have a bit of a reputation. I like things a certain way. The right way.

I like to think of myself as a "recovering perfectionist", however. I hope I'm getting better. After all, I only spent *cough numberofminutes cough* looking for a version of this meme with proper punctuation! Seriously, though, I admit that the siren song of perfectionism has always held a certain lure for me. There is something so appealing about the idea of doing everything perfectly right. And perfectionism, although a futile pursuit, is one that our culture affirms and even idolizes.

Sometimes I think that those of us who are prone to perfectionism tend to think that the only thing wrong with the desire to be perfect is that it's impossible. We all know we can never get there, and that trying will ultimately prove futile. But the truth is, I think it doesn't even matter that perfection is impossible to attain, because even if we could accomplish it, I think we'd find that the accomplishment would let us down. Here's why.

1.  Perfect doesn't touch what we need it to touch.

When we think about being perfect, we have the idea that it means always being right, and always doing right. But in actual fact, to be truly perfect requires something different. Real perfection is not about "rightness"--moral self-improvement. That kind of perfection is actually a lowering of standards, because it's only superficial; it's on the outside. Real perfection would be through and through. In order to be truly perfect, we would need something to touch much deeper--to perfect our hearts, our souls. To make us patient, kind, joyful, humble, forgiving, unselfish. We would need not only to be right, but to be good.

Our real struggle for perfection, then, is over the primacy of self. Removing ourselves from the place of greatest importance is the only path to genuine goodness of heart. And, in a supreme irony, this is the one act that perfectionism will never allow us, because at its heart, perfectionism is all about self. The relentless pursuit of our desire to justify ourselves by our own means, through our own efforts, will yield nothing but an obsession with ourselves and our own outward appearance.

2.  Perfect can't grow what we want it to grow.

But what if I'm mistaken? What if we can achieve goodness through striving for perfection? People smarter than I have certainly thought so. Benjamin Franklin, for example, went to great lengths to record his detailed plan for mastering 13 essential virtues of the heart, including humility. However, I think on deeper examination, we have to acknowledge that even Franklin had to accomplish his plan through trial and error--and it turned out to be a lot of error. In fact, if you read Franklin's journal, you'll find that one of the primary things he learned during his attempt was finding himself "so much fuller of faults than I had imagined", and that is a very important piece of discovery. And in the end, not only does Franklin conclude that it is impossible for him to reach the perfection of virtue he has been striving for, but that, with regard to the problem of pride in particular, "even if I could conceive that I had completely overcome it, I should probably be proud of my humility."

So we see that even if we look deeper, past external self-improvement, to a higher standard or different definition of perfection, the virtues we then value can't be developed through a self-focused act of the will. We might, as Franklin says he did, make some improvement in the mastering the appearance of them, but not the substance. Patience, humility, perseverance, resilience, grace--all these are traits borne of suffering, trials, discomfort, surprise. In order to really grow and change, we have to mess things up, make fools of ourselves, fall down and get back up. We can't become the person we envision without making mistakes. True perfection--or the closest thing we can reach--is only arrived at through the experience of our own imperfection.

3.  Perfect won't do what we want it to do.

But why do we really want to be perfect anyway? I think it's because the idea of perfection isn't appealing only as an end in itself--its attraction is in what we think it will do for us. Deep down, we somehow believe that if we just do everything right, we can somehow make everything else go right too. Perfectionism is an effort to gain control, over ourselves and over our circumstances. If we can just do everything exactly right, we can make sure of the outcomes for the people, interactions, situations, and relationships that make up our lives. Things will always go the way we hope. Certainly, at least, no one will ever be able to look down on us, criticize us, be angry with us, or dislike us if we are perfect. Being perfect will make us good enough, in our own eyes and in the eyes of others. In other words, we believe that our perfection will protect both our loved ones and ourselves from the unexpected, the undesirable, and from failure, pain, and rejection.

The unfortunate truth is that perfection can't cause any of this to happen, or keep any of it from happening. Life is unpredictable, and the world is sometimes a painful and scary place. Bad things happen. They happen to us, and to the people we love. Sometimes this is because we make mistakes, but not always. Sometimes it's because other people make mistakes. And sometimes it's just the way the world is. It's broken, and we can never fix it all on our own. We can only do our best, and even then, even if our best was perfect, it is no guarantee that things will go right, or that others will love us, accept us, or approve of us. As long as we live as broken people in a broken world, there will be tragedy and loss--we will hurt each other, and things that no one understands will sometimes happen. No matter how perfect we are, nothing can change this.

So what can we say then? If the pursuit of perfection is empty, what good can we take away? I think there is still something. The beauty in the complete barrenness, the empty promise that is perfectionism, is that it reminds us who we are. We are the Beloved. And as the Beloved, it is not our job to do any of the things we have tried to accomplish through our own perfection. We cannot save ourselves from pain, failure, or loss; we cannot make ourselves loved, accepted, respected; we cannot ensure that everything in our world will go right; and we do not have to. We were not created for this purpose. As the Beloved, we were created to be loved. And so we are. We need do nothing to earn it, and nothing that we or anyone else can do, say, or think, can change it. Our value is secure--our welfare is assured. Perfection can never offer us either.

Friday, September 23, 2016

Turn It Down

 
I don't know about you, but sometimes, I feel like nobody's listening to me. I talk to my kids--or at least I try--but it seems nothing's getting through.

"Are you even listening to me?"

"Am I talking to myself?"

"Have you heard one word I've said?"

"Hellooo! You!"

"Is my voice invisible?"
 
Now that I have teenagers, the most common scenario (and my least favorite) is the one where I try to get their attention but they have headphones on or earbuds in. This one often starts with my talking to them from the other room, so I don't realize they have any reason other than the usual for not answering, when I say something that requires a response.
 
I get no answer, so I say it again, this time louder.
 
Still nothing. The third time I don't want to waste my breath saying the whole thing over, so I just call out their name.
 
No answer. Now I have stopped whatever I was doing, I'm on my way to find them and figure out what the problem is, and I'm on the fourth attempt to get their attention, so it's easy to call their name pretty loud. It's also pretty easy to tell that I'm annoyed.

Getting within view and spotting the offending headphones doesn't dispel any of the annoyance, but it does make me call them even louder the next time. By this time I'm usually standing almost right next to them. Aaand I'm pretty much shouting. Even then I still often have to do it more than once. And finally, about the time I get to THIS LEVEL OF FRUSTRATION AND VOLUME, they turn around, pull off the headphones, and say, in an offended and angry tone, "WHAT!" 
 
Because I'm yelling at them. They don't like yelling.

Actually, I don't like yelling either. I don't like yelling, and I don't like being yelled at. Honestly, I don't like it when someone is angry with me, period. And I especially don't like it when they are angry with me for being The Yelling Mom, when I feel it's hardly my fault that it takes 8 minutes and a brass band to get their attention.

This isn't the only time this happens, of course. There are other times when they think I am Yelling Mom. For example, any day that I straggle home exhausted from work to find chores undone, trash everywhere, dirty dishes galore, and them in front of video games, I am that mom. And every time, they are angry.

Why do I have to yell at them? Why do I have to keep telling them what they're doing wrong? Why am I interrupting them right when they were about to win? Why do I always have to be so mad??

I get it. Nobody likes to have their fun interrupted by an unpleasant reminder of how they have messed up, or how that mess-up has disappointed, hurt, or angered someone else. A reminder delivered by the disappointed, hurt, and angry someone is even more unpleasant. But the conversation we keep having is, can they expect anything else? If they ignore me when I speak or give directions, if they choose not to take responsibility, if they disregard basic rules of conduct for the household, isn't it reasonable to assume that I will not be happy? And when this happens, guess what? You don't get to be angry about it. Mom's displeasure is a logical and expected result of your actions. 

Right now, every day, as I watch TV or read Facebook, I see this same dynamic being played out all around us, on the stage of race relations in this country. And there is something I want to say to those of us in the white community.

I get it. It's not pleasant to hear about the wrongs that have been done to others on our watch, and it's especially unpleasant to contemplate our own responsibility in them, even if our complicity is simply our own obliviousness. It's tempting to avoid doing so by taking issue with the way the message is being delivered. But friends, please realize what's happening--we have had the headphones on.

We have had the headphones on, and it is time now--time to turn down the music of our own comfortable narrative, and listen to what our brothers and sisters of color have been trying, repeatedly, over many long years, to get our attention to tell us. Time to stop being angry about the tone of voice or the choice of words or the forum used to communicate the message, and take the time to understand the hurt, anger, and frustration that is a result of not only others', but our own actions. Time to stop dictating to people of color the ways that are acceptable to us for them to express their responses to our behavior. We just simply haven't been listening, not for a long, long, time. It's time to start.

Tuesday, September 20, 2016

True Story


One of my favorite pieces of writing, recently, is a blog post by author Sarah Bessey entitled Off Brand. In it, Bessey uses her marketing background to explore the idea of branding--the way that companies try to define their corporate identity by establishing parameters that say, "this is who we are, this is what we do, this is how we do it"--and how it also applies to individual identity. A brand, she says, is the story we are telling about ourselves to the world, and it is reflected in both the way others think about us, and the way we think about ourselves.

The concept of identity is a fluid one, and as such, it can change many times over a lifetime. As we grow and change, as our circumstances shift, or as events require, the primary way we define ourselves must naturally evolve to fit. Sometimes this process is gradual, an expected part of our life trajectory; sometimes it is desired and even highly anticipated. Sometimes, it is mandated by the advent of tragedy, the circumstances of necessity, or simply the fact that life contains surprises that even the most prescient of us cannot hope to foresee. In those cases, Bessey says, we can sometimes experience an impulse to hold to our brand--to keep telling the same story--even when it no longer reflects what is true or best for us or those we love. "Sometimes," she says, "the story we tell ourselves about our own lives can become a prison, it can keep us from the real life that is waiting for us."

This idea resonates so strongly with me. Bessey's own story of struggle with brand transition is one of mothering, of how the experience of both birth and parenting with her youngest child was so different than the story she had previously told of herself as a mother that she believed she had failed both herself and her daughter. But I have experienced some of this same struggle many times in my life, as I have gone from wife, to teacher, to mother, to homemaker, to....well, whatever it is I am right now. I remember my shock at realizing, almost a full year after the change had happened, that someone who is working full-time hours probably should no longer think of herself as a stay-at-home-mom; somehow, my brain had failed to make the transition. No wonder I felt like such a terrible stay-at-home-mom. I wasn't one. And lest you think I learned my lesson over time, don't forget how recently you have heard me speak in these pages about sitting down with my sons and concluding that maybe it was no longer a reasonable expectation for us to gather at the table around a home-cooked meal every night; being a full-time (or more) working single parent of teenagers is yet another shift in brand from being a working wife, partner, and co-parent of young children. I was trying to tell an old story, and failing--the inevitable result when the story we try to tell about our lives no longer matches the reality.

Of all the times my brand has changed, however, none was more difficult than the realization that I must close the book on the story of teaching as my lifetime calling. I was a teacher, from a family of teachers, and I had known from my earliest days that I would always be a teacher. Those of you who know me have probably heard me talk about how, when I was very young, I didn't know that a person could grow up and be anything else--I thought everyone was a teacher. This was not about a career. This is who I was. That remained true as I finished my education, as I worked odd jobs looking for my first employment, and when I finally reached that milestone, my own classroom in my own school. I loved every student, every experience, every minute. I was where I belonged. But life, as it has a way of doing, intervened. My husband got a new job out of state. We had a baby, and then another. When people asked, "What do you do?" I still kept saying, "I'm a teacher," but I fretted about how many years I was missing in the classroom, how few I'd gotten to spend there, how few would be left to me. Time passes so quickly; so soon, I wasn't young anymore. And at some point it came time to realize that I would not only take, but had already taken, a different path. I was not a teacher. I would not be a teacher. It's hard to describe the depth of my lament for this loss--I was inconsolable.

As more time has passed, I have had the opportunity to do many other things, none of which would have been possible had I held to the story I had always imagined instead of the one that presented itself. I even had the opportunity to teach again, this time in a completely different setting and a completely different way, and it is an experience so close to my heart that I would never trade it for anything else I can possibly envision. And when the possibility presented itself of returning to the classroom in the way I once dreamed of, I found that not only my life, but even myself, had changed in ways that meant I would no longer choose that path, even if I could. I work now at a job I love, for a cause I am passionate about, with incredible people, and in a way that is perfect for me and my family, the way we are right now. And I suppose I believed that my past identity was in the past.

In fact, I suppose the reason I have so often had difficulty with telling a new story to myself and to the world about who I am, is that I have believed that all my past identities are in the past--that embracing the new story means replacing the old. But this week, I've had cause to reconsider. 

On Facebook, I got a message. "Miss Sheltra, were you my fourth grade teacher?" A former student, now grown, of course. And I cannot tell you what it has been like to look at his pictures, hear about his amazing life and accomplishments, and to be told that, in his story, I am remembered. So I have been thinking about what happens when our lives change, when circumstances shift, and our story changes. Until now, without evidence to the contrary, I have felt that each new story represents a loss of the old--that all the previous people I was, stories I told, must be discarded as no longer valid, having no more value, now that there is a new and better version. But I have been wrong. A good story is always a good story.

My student's voice has been, for me, like a marker that proves the ongoing existence of that other, former me. It testifies to the continued reality of a story I am no longer living. "You were the best; I always remember you." I am someone else now; but I was there, and I am still a player in that story. All is not lost or forgotten. I was there, and all the stories are still true.

Life is unpredictable, and time and circumstances may create of us a different parent, spouse, friend, or simply a different person. In our lifetimes, the story of who we are will change, and change, and change again.  But all the stories remain true; all still hold value; there is room for all to be beloved. No matter how many times you may find yourself re-invented, you are still all the people you have been. You have not lost yourself. The work you have done, the lives you have touched, the time you have invested--their worth has not diminished. You have made a difference. You matter. Not just the you in the story you are telling now, but the you in all the stories you have told or will tell. Everything good that has come out of each of them remains, and you carry it with you. You were there, and all the stories are you--they are still you.

Sunday, September 4, 2016

Parenting: Communications from the Front

Txt: Mom can I go to Dairy Queen, (friend) is driving
Rply: Who else is going?
Txt: (Friends)
Rply: OK, that's fine. Four people in the car is enough. Don't do anything stupid and don't die. And stop rolling your eyes at me, I'm your mother.
Txt: Mom its fine
Rply: Have fun.

Txt: Forgot key
Rply: OK, I'll drop it off for you. Where is it?
--------------
(Later, at the school)
M: "This is an extra key, I couldn't find yours. Where is it?"
B: "I don't know." (Shrugs, puts hands in pockets)
B: "Wait. I think I found it."

Txt: I should not have to text you from inside the house. Come downstairs.

(At end of school day, after being informed that I will come to pick him up)
Txt: Am I supposed to get on the bus?
Rply: No
Txt: Ok where are you then?
Rply: DRIVING
Txt: Oh. Sorry.

Txt: Why are you on the way here or was tht meant for sombody else
Rply: I didn't tell you I was on the way there.
Txt: ok
Rply: Worse news--unidentified person on way there.
Txt: Lol no I just flipped through the previous txts on accident

(Leaving for work in the morning, beef jerky stick is discovered under windshield wiper of truck)
Txt: Have a nice snack. --annanymous

Txt: Are you alive?
Rply: Yes mom im alive
Txt: I assumed so, but it never hurts to check.